Exploring NYC: The 16 Best Martini Bars by Sara Kay

You’re about to embark on a tour of NYC’s finest martini bars, where each spot offers a unique twist on the beloved cocktail. “Exploring NYC: The 16 Best Martini Bars by Sara Kay” is your definitive guide to experiencing the city’s top-tier mixology, from the inventive offerings at Temple Bar in NoHo, with its olive oil martini and caviar bumps, to the plush, cozy atmosphere of The Clover Club in Carroll Gardens and its cornichon-infused gin martinis. Whether it’s the panoramic views at Overstory in the Financial District or the artistic murals and high-end drinks at Bemelmans Bar on the Upper East Side, this carefully curated list highlights the signature martinis and distinctive features that make each venue a must-visit. Get ready to sip your way through New York’s best, one spectacular martini at a time. Have you ever wondered where to find the best martini in New York City? As you navigate the alluring maze of NYC’s nightlife, finding the perfect spot for that impeccable martini can feel like discovering a hidden gem. Lucky for you, renowned author Sara Kay has taken on the mission of curating the ultimate guide to the city’s top martini bars. Let’s explore these 16 exceptional venues that promise not just a drink but a memorable experience.

Exploring NYC: The 16 Best Martini Bars by Sara Kay

Get an Official Zagat Restaurant Guide

Temple Bar (NoHo)

Temple Bar stands as a beacon for inventive cocktails, with martinis taking center stage. Nestled in the vibrant neighborhood of NoHo, this bar offers unique options like olive oil martinis and caviar bumps — a blend of classic and contemporary.

Highlights

  • Signature Drinks: You must try the Summertime Sadness and Salt and Pepper Martini.
  • Atmosphere: A chic, yet relaxed setting perfect for unwinding after a hectic day.

Bemelmans Bar (Upper East Side)

Situated within the luxurious Carlyle Hotel, the Bemelmans Bar is a masterpiece of artistry and elegance. Adorned with Ludwig Bemelmans’ murals, it’s a hotspot for high-class martinis and an ambiance that takes you back in time.

Highlights

  • Signature Drinks: The Smokey Martini and savory Gibson are worth every penny.
  • Pricing: Though on the higher side, the quality and experience justify the cost.

Overstory (Financial District)

Perched on the 64th floor, Overstory provides breathtaking panoramic views of the city skyline. This bar pairs its spectacular scenery with equally impressive martinis and complementary snacks.

Highlights

  • Signature Drinks: The Last Frontier is a must-try.
  • Extras: Enjoy complementary cheddar chili lime popcorn as you sip your drink.
See also  London's 5 Toughest Tables

Get an Official Zagat Restaurant Guide

The Clover Club (Carroll Gardens)

If you’re looking for a cozy nook with plush seating and expertly crafted cocktails, The Clover Club in Carroll Gardens is your go-to. Known for pushing boundaries, this bar offers innovative martinis that will intrigue your palate.

Highlights

  • Signature Drinks: A Little Pickle, which uses cornichon-infused gin.
  • Setting: A warm and inviting environment perfect for intimate gatherings.

Death & Co. (East Village)

A pioneer in NYC’s cocktail culture, Death & Co. offers a menu that could easily be described as art. They maintain a relaxed, first-come, first-serve policy, ensuring an unpretentious yet sublime experience.

Highlights

  • Signature Drinks: Try the tropical Star Map martini, featuring coconut gin and dill aquavit.
  • Atmosphere: A laid-back vibe that’s perfect for a casual evening out.

Caviar Russe (Upper East Side)

Caviar Russe is where luxury meets epicurean delight. Known for its top-tier caviar and Michelin-starred dishes, this bar also boasts an impressive martini selection during their Martini Hour.

Highlights

  • Signature Drinks: ALB Vodka Martini with a caviar coronet.
  • Experience: An indulgent escape into a world of finesse and flavor.

Exploring NYC: The 16 Best Martini Bars by Sara Kay

American Bar (West Village)

Styled like an old-world club, American Bar welcomes everyone to enjoy traditional martinis with a twist. It’s a cozy yet elegant spot perfect for unwinding.

Highlights

  • Signature Drinks: Don’t miss out on their Lychee and Espresso martinis.
  • Setting: A timeless ambiance that combines the best of both worlds.

Nobody Told Me (Multiple Locations)

Known for its trendy vibe and occasional celebrity sightings, Nobody Told Me is a must-visit. Despite its chic atmosphere, the bar offers reasonably priced martinis without compromising on quality.

Highlights

  • Signature Drinks: Popular choices include the Pornstar Martini and Clarified Dirty.
  • Affordability: Enjoy high-quality cocktails that won’t break the bank.

Lobby Bar (Chelsea)

Located within the iconic Hotel Chelsea, Lobby Bar is rich in history and character. This setting is ideal for those who appreciate a touch of luxury in their nightlife.

Highlights

  • Signature Drinks: Don’t miss the 1884 martini.
  • Extras: Martini oysters with the option to add luxurious caviar are a perfect pairing.

Maison Premiere (Williamsburg)

Inspired by New Orleans, Maison Premiere offers an opulent retreat for martini enthusiasts. The bar’s sumptuous decor and extensive cocktail menu make it a standout venue in Williamsburg.

Highlights

  • Signature Drinks: The Old King Cole martini, stirred tableside with Gordal olives.
  • Ambiance: A lavish, inviting atmosphere that makes every visit feel special.

Here’s a quick reference table to help you remember the key highlights:

Bar Name Signature Drink(s) Unique Features
Temple Bar Summertime Sadness, Salt and Pepper Martini Inventive martinis, Olive oil martinis, Caviar bumps
Bemelmans Bar Smokey Martini, Gibson Ludwig Bemelmans murals, Luxurious setting
Overstory The Last Frontier Panoramic city views, Complimentary snacks
The Clover Club A Little Pickle Cozy environment, Cornichon-infused gin
Death & Co. Star Map First-come, first-serve, Relaxed vibe
Caviar Russe ALB Vodka Martini Michelin-starred dishes, Caviar coronet
American Bar Lychee Martini, Espresso Martini Old-world club vibe, Open to all
Nobody Told Me Pornstar Martini, Clarified Dirty Trendy setting, Affordable drinks
Lobby Bar 1884 Martini Located in Hotel Chelsea, Martini oysters
Maison Premiere Old King Cole Martini New Orleans-inspired, Opulent atmosphere
See also  Turn Boxed Mac And Cheese Into The Ultimate Comfort Meal With A Canned Pantry Staple

Tips for Enjoying NYC’s Martini Scene

Before diving into the details of the remaining bars, here are a few tips to make the most out of your martini adventures in the Big Apple:

  1. Book Ahead: Some of these spots, particularly those with a luxury vibe, may require reservations.
  2. Time it Right: Happy Hours and Martini Hours often offer signature cocktails at a lower price.
  3. Dress Smart: While some venues are casual, others might have a dress code. It’s best to check in advance.
  4. Pace Yourself: With so many delectable options, it may be tempting to try every martini in one night. Spread your visits out to truly savor each experience.

Additional Must-Visit Martini Bars

While the earlier mentioned bars already offer a splendid martini experience, NYC’s cocktail scene is vast and varied. Here are a few more worth exploring:

Dear Irving (Gramercy)

Split across multiple floors, each themed in a different era, Dear Irving offers an eclectic experience. Whether you prefer the plush, Gatsby-esque vibes or a more intimate setting, this bar has it all.

Highlights

  • Signature Drinks: Try any of their bespoke martinis, crafted with the finest ingredients.
  • Ambiance: A time-traveling experience with each floor.

Raines Law Room (Flatiron)

This speakeasy-style bar prides itself on impeccable service and a quiet, intimate atmosphere. With its classic décor and luxurious ambiance, Raines Law Room offers a sanctuary in the bustling Flatiron District.

Highlights

  • Signature Drinks: Their classic martini is a must-have.
  • Setting: Relaxing, with a speakeasy feel and attentive service.

Little Branch (West Village)

For those who appreciate the finer details in cocktails, Little Branch is a gem. This bar focuses on the craftsmanship of drinks, with bartenders who are true artists.

Highlights

  • Signature Drinks: Their gin martinis are meticulously crafted.
  • Atmosphere: Intimate setting with live jazz often complementing the mood.

Employees Only (West Village)

Renowned for its creativity and flair, Employees Only is a staple in NYC’s bar scene. This Prohibition-style bar offers a cozy, vibrant atmosphere perfect for martini enthusiasts.

Highlights

  • Signature Drinks: The EO Martini, a house special.
  • Extras: The bar also offers tarot readings — a fun extra to your evening.

The Campbell (Midtown)

Located in Grand Central Terminal, The Campbell oozes historic charm. Once the office of John W. Campbell, this elegant space now serves finely crafted cocktails in a spectacular setting.

Highlights

  • Signature Drinks: Their classic martini is renowned.
  • Setting: A blend of luxury and history that transports you to another era.

Angel’s Share (East Village)

Known for its air of secrecy, Angel’s Share offers a serene ambiance away from the chaos of the streets. Tucked away behind an unassuming door, this bar is a haven for martini lovers.

Highlights

  • Signature Drinks: A variety of innovative martinis featuring exotic ingredients.
  • Atmosphere: Quiet, almost hidden setting ensuring a peaceful experience.
See also  Ultimate Istanbul Street Food Tour with Mark Wiens

Bar Goto (Lower East Side)

Bar Goto adds a Japanese twist to the traditional martini, offering a unique take that martini purists will love. It’s a serene, minimalist setting perfect for a relaxed evening.

Highlights

  • Signature Drinks: Try the Sakura Martini for a taste of something different.
  • Ambiance: A calming, almost Zen-like environment.

Attaboy (Lower East Side)

An unmarked door leads you into the heart of bespoke cocktails. Attaboy’s bartenders can craft a martini based on your personal preferences, making every visit unique.

Highlights

  • Signature Drinks: Personalized martinis tailored to your taste.
  • Experience: Truly bespoke cocktails in an intimate setting.

Bar SixtyFive (Midtown)

Situated in the iconic Rockefeller Center, Bar SixtyFive offers unbeatable views along with its delightful martinis. It’s a perfect spot for both tourists and locals looking to enjoy a cocktail with a view.

Highlights

  • Signature Drinks: Their classic martinis with a twist.
  • Extras: Stunning views of the New York City skyline.

PDT (Please Don’t Tell) (East Village)

Hidden behind a hot dog joint, PDT offers an exclusive, speakeasy experience. The bar’s unique entrance and creative cocktails make it a must-visit for any cocktail aficionado.

Highlights

  • Signature Drinks: Unique and creative martinis.
  • Atmosphere: Exclusive, with a hidden, speakeasy charm.

To make things even clearer, here’s another quick reference table:

Bar Name Signature Drink(s) Unique Features
Dear Irving Custom martinis Themed floors, eclectic setting
Raines Law Room Classic martini Speakeasy-style, intimate atmosphere
Little Branch Gin martini Craftsmanship of drinks, live jazz
Employees Only EO Martini Prohibition style, tarot readings
The Campbell Classic martini Historical, luxurious setting
Angel’s Share Innovative martinis Secluded, serene ambiance
Bar Goto Sakura Martini Japanese twist, minimalist atmosphere
Attaboy Personalized martinis Tailored drinks, intimate setting
Bar SixtyFive Classic martinis with a twist Breathtaking city views
PDT Creative martinis Hidden entrance, exclusive experience

Final Thoughts

Exploring NYC’s martini bars is more than just a night out — it’s an adventure filled with historical charm, innovative spirits, and a variety of ambiances to fit any mood. Whether you’re a seasoned martini connoisseur or someone looking to expand your cocktail horizons, this guide by Sara Kay ensures you’ll find the perfect spot in the city that never sleeps.

So, ready your palate and don your best evening wear, because the best martini bars in NYC await you. Here’s to unforgettable nights and impeccable martinis. Enjoy!

Get an Official Zagat Restaurant Guide

You cannot copy content of this page